Increasing Cultural Competence in Career Counseling As the workforce becomes more diverse across race, ethnicity, gender identity, socioeconomic status, immigration experiences, age, and ability, cultural competence in career counseling has become essential, not optional. Even though economic downturns are often described as affecting everyone in the same way, research shows that unemployment, underemployment, job access, and workplace treatment vary widely…
Read More →
Using Mindfulness to Address Your Fears By Richard Orbé-Austin, PhD Mindfulness for fear works by helping your brain shift out of fight-or-flight and into calm awareness. Instead of avoiding fear or suppressing it, mindfulness teaches you to observe your physical sensations, thoughts, and emotions without judgment—reducing reactivity and allowing the fear response to settle naturally. Fear is one of the…
Read More →
Where Does Imposter Syndrome Come From? Understanding Its Roots, Psychology, and How to Overcome It Quick Answer Where does Imposter Syndrome come from? It often develops through early family messages, perfectionistic expectations, and social environments that equate worth with achievement. Over time, these beliefs form chronic self-doubt—even in accomplished people. Because it’s learned, Imposter Syndrome can be unlearned through reflection,…
Read More →
Career & Leadership • Authentic Connection
By Dr. Lisa Orbé-Austin | Dynamic Transitions LLP
Relational vs transactional networking is the difference between collecting contacts and cultivating a community. Specifically, relational networking builds authentic, long-term professional relationships grounded in mutual respect and shared value, whereas transactional networking seeks quick personal gain with minimal investment. Consequently, when you shift to a relational approach, you increase trust, credibility, and opportunity—for both of you.
I get asked this question constantly: “How do I get more people to respond to my networking requests?” As a result, the solution must be simple yet deep: move from transactional networking to relational networking. Ultimately, when you do, networking stops being a numbers game and becomes an ongoing conversation that grows your influence, credibility, and confidence. This article shows how relational vs transactional networking impacts response rates and long-term opportunity.
Transactional networking is fast, direct, and focused on one thing: What can you do for me? It’s the “Veruca Salt” approach to connection—“I want it now!”—and it often sounds like this:
“Hi X, I’m currently the regional manager at XYZ Company and hope to work at your organization. Could we find time to chat?”
Reality Check
From the receiver’s perspective, that reads as: “This person wants something.” Moreover, the people you most want to reach are usually influential, busy, and already fielding constant requests. Without context or rapport, your message blends into the noise. If networking itself feels draining, try reframing with these ideas on career ruts and meaningful pivots.
It violates the core principle of human behavior: reciprocity. A request without relationship can feel extractive, even if your intention is sincere. In networking, perception trumps intention—people respond to how you make them feel, not just what you mean. Consequently, leaders who practice relational vs transactional networking build durable reputations rooted in trust.
When someone feels like a target instead of a collaborator, they disengage. The antidote is connection. For a research lens on reciprocity and relationship-building, see Harvard Business Review’s work on professional relationships and the APA’s resources on prosocial behavior.
Relational networking is about building community, not collecting contacts. It’s the belief that we grow faster together. Instead of “How can you help me?” you’re asking “How can we add value to each other over time?” That’s how opportunity, credibility, and new ideas compound. Therefore, keep relational vs transactional networking front and center as you evaluate your outreach approach.
If self-doubt tends to spike before outreach, these strategies to overcome Imposter Syndrome at work can help you show up with clarity and confidence.
Do your homework: read their posts, interviews, or talks. Identify authentic overlap (industry, mission, alma mater). Lead with appreciation and shared context—not your goals. To ground your outreach in your growth goals, revisit your performance review objectives so you can articulate value clearly.
Example outreach: “Hi Alex, your post on mentoring emerging leaders really resonated with me—especially the part about listening before advising. I’d love to connect and keep learning from your work.”
Engage regularly without expectation. Comment thoughtfully, share relevant articles, and celebrate their milestones. Ask yourself, “What can I give?”—a resource, an introduction, or amplification to your audience. If you’re prone to overcommitting, this article on the Work Martyr Complex can help you set healthier boundaries.
Check in periodically without an agenda. Share insights, ask a sincere question, or send encouragement. Relationships thrive on care and consistency—long after the first message.
Many high achievers rush to “the ask” because networking feels awkward—or because Imposter Syndrome whispers, “Prove you belong.” That urgency short-circuits connection. However, you can pause to examine the story underneath and rewrite it.
Related: practical ways to reset during career ruts.
Email A – Transactional: “Hi Janet, I admire your career and would love to get a job at your company. Can you refer me?”
Result: Silence.
Email B – Relational: “Hi Janet, your interview on sustainable leadership—especially ‘building systems that last’—was outstanding. I’m exploring similar themes and would love to connect.”
Result: Connection accepted, plus an invite to a roundtable. Moreover, leaders who practice relational vs transactional networking experience more organic introductions.
Relational ≠ limitless access. Healthy networking requires discernment. Therefore, ask: Am I giving from generosity or guilt? Am I overcommitting to be liked, or engaging to be respected?
Shift the question: from “Who can help me?” to “Who can I learn from—and support?” Curiosity fuels energy; performance anxiety drains it. If you need a structured reboot, try the one-week give-first experiment below and journal your observations (what surprised you, who responded, what you learned).
In a world of automation and AI, trust is your competitive edge. It’s the reason your name surfaces in rooms you’re not yet in. When you invest in relationships, opportunities unfold naturally: collaborations, referrals, partnerships—and friendships that sustain you through transitions. Ultimately, keep practicing relational vs transactional networking to compound trust over time.
“If I succeed, then you succeed.” That’s the core philosophy of relational networking. For deeper mindset work around visibility and recognition, see our guide on overcoming Imposter Syndrome at work.
Spend one week only giving. Offer value, gratitude, or amplification—no asks. Notice how much comes back organically. For additional structure, align your outreach with goals from your latest performance review so your relationship-building supports your growth plan.
Think of one person who supported your growth. What made that relationship feel genuine? What would it look like to offer that same energy to others this quarter? If you tend to overextend, these insights on the Work Martyr Complex can help you set sustainable boundaries.
Relational networking centers mutual growth and trust over time, while transactional networking seeks quick results with minimal investment in the relationship. For a research overview, explore HBR’s relationship-building coverage.
Acknowledge it, clarify your intent, and re-engage with curiosity. People respond to authenticity and growth. If self-doubt is a blocker, start with these Imposter Syndrome strategies.
Think in seasons, not sprints. Genuine relationships mature over months or years—but the impact is lasting.
Absolutely. People are far more likely to champion those they already trust. Start now—before you “need” help.
Depth beats breadth. Engage with one person a week with a sincere comment, message, or note.
